Most bad seed orders start the same way: a cold evening, a stack of catalogs, and a growing list of tomatoes with beautiful names. By April, there are 14 varieties competing for six cages, not enough carrot seed for a second sowing, and an onion variety that was never suited to your latitude.

A good seed order starts with your growing conditions, your available space, and what you actually want to harvest. The catalog then becomes a technical reference instead of a temptation. Here’s how to read the listings, decide what’s worth buying, and calculate quantities before popular varieties start selling out.

Start With an Inventory, Not a Catalog

Before you open a catalog, go through the seed you already have. Sort it by crop and note the year each packet was packed. Age matters because some seeds stay viable far longer than others. These are approximate lifespans under decent storage conditions:

  • 1 to 2 years — onions, leeks, parsnips, and sweet corn
  • 2 to 3 years — peppers, spinach, beans, peas, and carrots
  • 4 to 5 years — tomatoes, beets, brassicas, squash, cucumbers, and lettuce

If you aren’t sure about a packet, run a germination test. Place 20 seeds on a damp paper towel, fold it, seal it in a plastic bag, and keep it somewhere warm. Check it over the next one to two weeks, allowing longer for slow crops like peppers. If 16 seeds sprout, your germination rate is about 80%. That seed is still usable, but you’ll need to sow a little more heavily. If only 8 or 10 sprout, replace it unless the variety is hard to find.

Next, review last season. Which varieties produced well, which ones failed, and what did you run out of? If you logged sowing dates, varieties, and harvests in a tool like CropsBook, this takes minutes rather than an evening of trying to remember which cherry tomato split after every rain.

What the Catalog Terms Actually Mean

Catalog descriptions are written to sell seed, but the technical details are usually reliable. These are the terms most worth understanding:

  • Days to maturity — an estimate, not a promise. Direct-sown crops are generally counted from sowing or emergence, while crops usually started indoors, like tomatoes and peppers, are counted from transplanting. A 75-day tomato may need another six to eight weeks of indoor growing first.
  • F1 hybrid — a cross between two selected parent lines, often chosen for uniformity, vigor, or disease resistance. Saved seed won’t reliably match the parent plant.
  • Open-pollinated — a variety that produces similar offspring if you prevent cross-pollination. It’s the practical choice if you plan to save seed.
  • Heirloom — an open-pollinated variety with a long history. It says something about its background, not necessarily its flavor or performance in your garden.
  • Determinate and indeterminate — determinate tomatoes reach a set size and ripen much of their crop in a concentrated window. Indeterminate types keep growing and produce until disease or frost stops them.
  • Pelleted seed — small seed coated in clay to make it easier to handle and space. Buy only what you’ll use within about a year, since pelleted seed loses viability faster than raw seed.
  • Treated seed — seed coated with fungicide or another protectant, typically to reduce rot and seedling disease. If you’re certified organic or planning to be, check the listing and your certifier’s requirements before ordering.
Treat days to maturity as a way to compare varieties in the same catalog. Your own planting dates and harvest records will tell you what those numbers mean in your garden.

Disease resistance codes are often the most valuable part of a listing, and they usually appear in abbreviated form. In tomatoes, you may see V for verticillium wilt, F for fusarium wilt, N for root-knot nematodes, and LB for late blight. Catalogs may also separate high resistance (HR) from intermediate resistance (IR). Resistance doesn’t mean immunity, and code conventions vary, so check the key in each catalog. Then match those codes to the problems you’ve actually had. Paying extra for nematode resistance won’t help much if you’ve never had nematodes, but powdery mildew resistance can be well worth it if your squash collapses from mildew every August.

Match Varieties to Your Season and Setup

A variety that wins praise in a Georgia trial may be a poor choice in northern Minnesota. Before falling for a listing, check it against the realities of your site.

  • Count your growing window — find the days between your average last spring frost and first fall frost, then leave a two-week buffer for cooler autumn weather and shorter days. An 85-day melon transplanted late may not ripen before the season ends.
  • Check day length for onions — long-day varieties generally suit northern gardens, short-day types suit the South, and intermediate types fill much of the middle. The wrong type can produce small bulbs no matter how well you grow it.
  • Pick for the season — a lettuce variety that does well in April may bolt in July. Look for separate spring, summer, and fall recommendations rather than treating all varieties as interchangeable.
  • Consider pollination — parthenocarpic cucumbers set fruit without pollination, making them useful under insect netting or in a tunnel. Other cucumbers rely on insects, so they need access to pollinators. If you keep bees alongside your vegetables, HiveBook can help you track colony activity and honey production while you manage the garden separately.
  • Consider the end use — paste tomatoes for canning, storage onions for winter, and thin-skinned salad tomatoes for market all call for different traits. Choose for how you’ll use or sell the crop, not just how it looks in the photo.

Keep the growing conditions you can’t change in mind as well. Heavy clay can make long carrots a frustrating choice, while a shorter Nantes or Chantenay type may perform better. Limited space favors compact bush varieties or crops that climb. Mixed farms may have another consideration: if you’re growing mangels, fodder beets, or turnips as supplemental feed, plan those beds with your animals’ needs in mind and keep herd and feed records in Barnsbook.

Do the Seed Math

Most ordering mistakes come from guessing. A simple calculation works for almost every crop:

Seeds needed = plants wanted ÷ (germination rate × survival rate)

Say you want 24 tomato plants. With 85% germination and 90% of seedlings surviving to transplant, you’ll need 24 ÷ (0.85 × 0.90), or about 32 seeds. Add a few for spares and start 35.

For direct-sown crops, work from row length and sowing density:

  1. Find your total row feet — include every planned succession. Three sowings of 30 feet means 90 feet, not 30.
  2. Multiply by seeds per foot — 100 feet of carrots at 30 seeds per foot requires 3,000 seeds.
  3. Convert to the catalog’s unit — at roughly 20,000 carrot seeds per ounce, that’s 0.15 ounces. A quarter-ounce gives you some margin.

Seed counts vary by variety, so check the listing when it provides a count per ounce or per packet. Don’t assume two packets contain the same amount, either. One may hold 25 seeds and another 500, and the price per seed can differ dramatically.

Compare seed prices per thousand seeds, not per packet. The cheapest-looking packet is often the most expensive seed on the page.

Succession crops are where the math pays off most. If you want to harvest 25 heads of lettuce a week for 16 weeks, you need 400 heads. At 90% germination and 85% survival to harvest, that’s about 525 seeds, split across varieties suited to each part of the season. A planting plan in CropsBook gives you those numbers in one place, so you can base next year’s order on what you actually sowed.

Ready to put this into practice? Download CropsBook on the App Store — it’s free and works offline.

Set a Limit on New Varieties

New varieties are part of the fun, but too many trials make it hard to learn anything and can leave you dependent on unproven crops. A simple working rule is to devote about 80% of your space to proven varieties and leave 20% for experiments.

Make those trials useful by keeping them small and comparing them fairly:

  • Plant next to a standard — grow the new variety beside the one it may replace, on the same date and in similar soil.
  • Decide what you’re testing — earliness, flavor, disease tolerance, or yield. A single clear question makes the result easier to judge.
  • Write down your verdict — note “keep,” “replace,” or “try once more” at the end of the season, along with the reason.

Market growers should be even more cautious. Trial new crops on a scale you can afford to lose, and test whether customers will actually buy them before filling a bed with something unfamiliar.

Choose Suppliers and Time Your Order

Popular varieties and small-batch seed can sell out by midwinter, so aim to place your main order between November and January. Crops with unusual logistics deserve an early look, including seed potatoes, onion plants, and sweet potato slips. These are often reserved in winter and shipped closer to planting time, so confirm the shipping window suits your climate.

A few supplier details are worth checking:

  • Regional fit — seed companies that trial varieties in a climate like yours often give more relevant descriptions and recommendations.
  • Germination information — look for a stated test date or germination rate, particularly when buying larger quantities.
  • Clear disease codes — catalogs that publish a resistance key make varieties much easier to compare.
  • Shipping thresholds — combining orders with one or two suppliers can reduce shipping costs compared with buying a few packets from many places.
  • Certification needs — certified organic growers generally need to use organic seed when a suitable equivalent is commercially available and document their search if it isn’t. Keep your receipts and ask your certifier what records they expect.

Store Seed So Your Money Lasts

Heat and humidity are what shorten seed life. A common guideline, known as Harrington’s rule, says storage is generally safe when the temperature in Fahrenheit plus the percent relative humidity adds up to less than 100. A cool, dry closet may qualify, while a garage, shed, or greenhouse bench usually won’t.

  1. Label everything — include the variety, supplier, and year on every packet.
  2. Use an airtight container — a jar or sealed plastic tub with a silica gel packet works well.
  3. Keep it cool and dark — a basement shelf or refrigerator is ideal if the container is truly airtight.
  4. Let cold containers warm before opening — this prevents condensation from forming on the seed.
  5. File by sowing month — sorting packets by when they’ll be used keeps time-sensitive sowings from being forgotten.
A seed order is really a season plan with prices attached. If you can’t say where a variety will grow and when you’ll sow it, leave it in the catalog.

Before you check out, make one final pass through your cart. Assign every variety to a bed and sowing date, recheck the quantities against your succession plan, and cut anything without a place. What remains should be an order that fits your season, your space, and your budget, with a little room left for one irresistible new tomato.